SAYIŞTAY PRESIDENTS SHOULD HAVE RECOGNIZED THE AUDIT GAPS!

The Republic of Türkiye was founded on the separation of powers between the legislature, executive and judiciary. For this system to function properly, the state must be subject to oversight and those who govern must be accountable.

The economic and financial problems we face today, particularly the events publicly referred to as the “fund robbery,” have once again brought serious shortcomings in the state’s oversight system to the fore.

Sayıştay is foremost among the institutions that should have recognized and identified these gaps before anyone else and taken action to have them addressed.

A CONSTITUTIONAL DUTY CANNOT BE RENDERED INEFFECTIVE BY LEGISLATION!

Article 160 of the Constitution assigns Sayıştay the duty of auditing public administrations’ revenues, expenditures and assets on behalf of the TBMM. Parliament may regulate audit procedures by law, but it cannot render constitutionally mandated oversight ineffective.

Law No. 4149, enacted in 1996, strengthened Sayıştay’s powers and explicitly provided for it to examine whether public resources were being used efficiently, effectively and economically.

The aim was to examine not only whether money was spent in accordance with the law, but also how it was used in economic terms.

However, Article 36 of Law No. 6085, enacted in 2010, narrowed this approach by defining performance auditing in terms of targets and indicators set by the administration itself.

Significant portions of the additional restrictions introduced in 2012 were annulled by the Constitutional Court’s judgment dated 27.12.2012, numbered E.2012/102, K.2012/207.

The Court established that examining whether public resources were used effectively, economically and efficiently could not, in itself, be considered a prohibited review of the merits of administrative decisions.

Yet the narrow definition of performance auditing introduced in 2010 remained in force.

As a result, a serious issue requiring clarification emerged concerning the relationship between Sayıştay’s constitutional duty and the legislation governing how that duty is carried out.

WHO OVERSEES THE OVERSIGHT BODIES?

This is where the real issue begins.

Key financial institutions such as the Central Bank, SPK, BDDK and TMSF are subject to various forms of oversight. But auditing their financial accounts does not mean that the economic consequences of their regulatory, supervisory, resolution and liquidation activities are also adequately examined.

For example, Article 81 of Law No. 6085 limits Sayıştay’s auditing of the Central Bank to accounts and transactions outside the Bank’s core duties and powers.

Similarly, auditing SPK’s expenditure does not mean that the effectiveness of its supervision of capital markets is comprehensively examined.

The Türkiye Wealth Fund, meanwhile, is subject to a special audit regime that differs from Sayıştay’s ordinary auditing procedures.

If there are gaps in the accountability of institutions that make the state’s most significant economic decisions, supervise financial markets and manage public assets, then the state’s oversight system itself must be called into question.

Some of the allegations concerning fund transactions, investor losses and other financial problems we face today could have been prevented or limited through more effective oversight and timely intervention.

Inadequate oversight can not only cause errors to compound but also delay the identification of those responsible.

WHY DID SAYIŞTAY PRESIDENTS NOT DRAW ATTENTION TO THESE GAPS?

This is the question that deserves our attention.

If existing laws do not adequately allow Sayıştay to fulfil its constitutionally assigned auditing duty, can its president be content merely to apply those laws?

Of course, the president must comply with the laws in force. But ignoring shortcomings that prevent the effective fulfilment of a constitutional duty is incompatible with institutional responsibility.

Moreover, Articles 38 and 42 of Law No. 6085 allow the findings of audits and examinations to be submitted to the TBMM.

Although these provisions do not give the president of Sayıştay the power to introduce legislation directly or impose an explicit obligation to propose legislative amendments, identifying structural problems that prevent the fulfilment of its constitutional duty and reporting them to the competent authorities is a matter of institutional responsibility.

This is therefore the responsibility not only of the current president of Sayıştay, but of all those who have held the office.

When the broader approach to auditing introduced in 1996 was narrowed in 2010, when new restrictions were imposed in 2012, and when gaps emerged in the oversight of financial institutions, Sayıştay presidents should have recognized these problems and brought them before Parliament.

Today, too, the president of Sayıştay should submit a report to the TBMM setting out the existing audit gaps and the legislative amendments needed, together with the reasons for them.

The president is not expected to change the laws, but to identify which laws must be amended so that Sayıştay can fully discharge its constitutional duty.

HOW CAN AN AUDITOR WHO FAILS TO RECOGNIZE AN AUDIT GAP DO THE JOB?

Sayıştay should not be an institution that merely identifies mistakes made by public bodies. It must also be able to recognize shortcomings in its own auditing system.

A state’s strength is measured not by the powers held by those who govern it, but by how effectively those powers can be scrutinized.

Standing by as a constitutional auditing duty is rendered ineffective is incompatible with the responsibility to exercise oversight.

For this reason, the stance taken by former Sayıştay presidents on this issue must also be questioned, while the current president should submit the necessary proposals for regulatory changes to the TBMM without delay.

Because power that cannot be scrutinized eventually becomes power that cannot be held to account.

Prof. Dr. Mete Gündoğan

More articles by this author

Mirat Haber – YouTube

 

Recent Posts

  • General News

Trump seeks modernization funding after U.S. air traffic crisis disrupts flights

After an air traffic crisis temporarily halted flights across the United States, Trump asked Congress…

26 minutes ago
  • General News

Pınar Altuğ reportedly sold Bebek apartment for 85 million lira

Sabah columnist Bülent Cankurt claims Pınar Altuğ sold her Bebek apartment for 85 million lira.…

38 minutes ago
  • General News

Virtual worship on TikTok: Coins buy effects and visibility

According to CNN TÜRK, some TikTok streams link digital depictions of religious rituals to coins.…

54 minutes ago
  • General News

Uğur Bilgin and İrem Uslu welcome their first child

Uğur Bilgin, who plays Mesut in Güldür Güldür Show, has become a father. The actor…

59 minutes ago
  • General News

Beşiktaş linked with Amad Diallo in search for a right winger

Beşiktaş have reportedly identified Manchester United's Amad Diallo as a mid-season target. The €45 million…

1 hour ago
  • General News

Instagram’s standalone Direct app is being tested in Turkey and Thailand

Meta is testing Direct in Turkey and Thailand, Onedio reports. The app syncs with Instagram…

2 hours ago