
A lie is any fabricated statement or wrongful act intended to present or describe something as other than it is, in order to harm someone else or benefit oneself, increase one’s comfort, or at least avoid compromising that comfort.
A lie is an utterance of disbelief—the false speech of an unbeliever who covers up the truth with lies and conceals reality. But it is not, and can never be, something a Muslim says. For the Messenger of Allah gave this warning very clearly and explicitly: a believer may steal or commit adultery, but a believer can never lie. If they lie, that settles the whole matter. Where there is lying, there is no need to look for another sin, because all sins and evils have already lined up alongside it.
Ebu’d-Derda comes to the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) and asks: “O Messenger of Allah! Can a Muslim drink alcohol?” The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) says, “He may (he may err, he may have fallen into sin).” He asks, “Can a Muslim steal?” The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) says, “He may.” He asks, “Can a Muslim commit adultery?” Our beloved Prophet replies, “Yes, he may.” Then Ebu’d-Derdâ asks: “But does he lie?” At that moment, the noble Messenger of Allah, who had been reclining, sits upright and answers angrily: “A Muslim does not lie. Only someone who does not believe fabricates lies.” (Kenzu’l Ummal, Hadith no. 8994) When our beloved Prophet, with these words, regards lying as the foundation, the mother of all sins, what are we to make of our indifference as Muslims? How can we explain it? Fund fraud, the scourge of favoritism, the ihram lie, and so on and so forth—are these not all our shame, our disgrace? Without going into detail, consider the example of the “IHRAM LIE” and judge for yourselves just how far we have taken lying, our own dishonesty. At the Kaaba, voluntary tawaf, apart from the tawaf of umrah, is performed without ihram. Under the current arrangements, this tawaf, which we perform without ihram, takes place on the upper floor and lasts approximately 2 hours. Tawaf immediately beside the Kaaba, an area reserved solely for those in ihram for umrah to prevent overcrowding, takes half an hour. Now tell this humble soul: instead of doing what is difficult but right, choosing nothing but your own ease and comfort and CLOAKING YOURSELF IN THE IHRAM LIE so you can perform tawaf downstairs—IS THAT NOT AN ENORMOUS LIE?
What do people use to deceive themselves? LIES… the lies they tell themselves. If someone tells another person a lie, the day will come when they admit it. But if they have become fixated on the lie they tell themselves, they no longer have any will, conscience, or sense of fairness left with which to defend the truth. They know and see this lie perfectly well, but they do not want to confront the guilty face that the truth would reveal, or face their own sin and lies. They have now bound and condemned themselves not to truth and what is right, but to lies and what is wrong. Of course, speaking the truth, saying what is right, comes at a price, but that price brings a person dignity, honor, standing, and character. THE PRICE OF LYING, HOWEVER, IS ONE’S VERY SELF AND ONE’S HUMANITY. All of it is lost.
“Know that Allah knows what is within you!”(Bakara, 2/235) Let us listen closely to this warning from the Most Merciful, and as we outwit and deceive everyone with our tongues, let us feel reverence and shame before our Lord, who knows what is within us! Out of respect for Allah, let us at last repent of lies both small and great, and remain human—indeed, let us be good human beings, please…
Nuri Çalışkan
Mirat Haber – YouTube