
In Islam, the rights of others are among the matters that demand the greatest care. Violating another person’s rights is not merely a sin against Allah; it is also an infringement of that person’s rights. Failing to pray, fast or perform another act of worship violates Allah’s rights. Taking someone’s property, damaging their honour, slandering them, usurping their rights or treating them unjustly, however, violates the rights of a human being.
At this point, an important question arises: although Allah Most High has declared that He may forgive any sin He wills other than associating partners with Him, can violations of others’ rights not be forgiven in the hereafter?
Almighty Allah says in our Book of Life: “Indeed, Allah does not forgive associating partners with Him. He forgives sins other than this for whomever He wills.” (4/Nisa:48). This verse shows how vast Allah’s forgiveness is. Yet there is an important detail to consider when understanding it. Violating another person’s rights is not merely a sin against Allah. It is also an infringement of a human being’s rights. Thus, alongside seeking Allah’s forgiveness, we must also uphold the rights of the person who has been wronged. Here, Allah’s forgiveness and His justice are not opposing concepts. Allah is both forgiving and just. He never wrongs His servants.
On this subject, the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said: “Whoever has wronged a fellow believer should seek that person’s pardon before the Day of Resurrection comes, when there will be neither dinars nor dirhams.” (Buhârî, Mezâlim, 10; Rikāk, 48). This hadith reveals how serious a matter the rights of others will be in the hereafter. In this world, debts between people can be paid with money. In the hereafter, however, this will not be possible. There, accounts will be settled through good and evil deeds.
In another hadith, our Prophet described the truly bankrupt person as follows: “A person comes on the Day of Resurrection with acts of worship such as prayer, fasting and zakat. But in this world, he has insulted someone, slandered another, consumed someone else’s property and oppressed other people. His good deeds are then given to those he has wronged. If his good deeds run out, some of their sins are taken and placed upon him.” (Müslim, Birr ve Sıla, 59).
This hadith teaches us a very important truth: No amount of worship removes our accountability for the wrongs we have done to others.
To free themselves of the burden of violating another person’s rights, those responsible must not be content with repentance alone. They must return usurped property to its owner, pay outstanding debts, seek pardon from the person they have wronged, restore as far as possible the reputation of anyone they have harmed through slander or backbiting, and try to make amends for the material and emotional harm they have caused. If the person whose rights were violated has died, they must make restitution to that person’s heirs.
So, are violations of others’ rights never forgiven in the hereafter? This question requires a careful answer. Allah’s declaration that He will forgive sins other than associating partners with Him for whomever He wills does not mean that everyone who violates another person’s rights will necessarily be punished. Likewise, Allah’s forgiveness does not mean that the person who was wronged will necessarily go uncompensated. Islam’s fundamental principle is justice. No one’s rights will be lost in the hereafter. Yet Allah Most High’s mercy and bounty are also infinite. No sin, including a violation of another person’s rights, can place a restriction on Allah’s pardon and forgiveness. By giving from His own treasury, Allah can satisfy the servant who is owed restitution, lead that person to relinquish the claim, and save the servant who violated their rights. It is therefore not right to say, “Allah will never forgive” a violation of another person’s rights.
In the tenth book of his work “İhyâu Ulûm’i Dîn,” in the 36th discourse of the section “Death and What Follows,” under the heading “The State of the Disputants and the Restoration of Rights,” Imam Gazali quotes the following hadith, mentioned by Hakim in his work Müstedrek and by İbn Ebî Dünya in his discussion of “Thinking Well of Allah,” and transmitted from Enes b. Malik:
“Once, we saw the Messenger of Allah sitting, and he smiled so broadly that his blessed front teeth were visible. The venerable Ömer asked:
– O Messenger of Allah! May my mother and father be sacrificed for you. What has made you smile?
– Two people from my community are standing before Allah, the Possessor of Might. One of them says:
– “O my Lord! Avenge the wrong this brother of mine has done to me.” Thereupon, Almighty Allah says to the wrongdoer:
– Pay the penalty for the wrong you have done to your brother.
– O my Lord! I have no good deeds left.
Then Almighty Allah says to the person who was wronged:
– What will you do? Look, he has no good deeds left.
The person who was wronged says:
– O my Lord! Let him bear some of my sins.
At this, the Messenger of Allah’s eyes filled with tears, and he said: “Indeed, that day is a day of great peril. It is a day when people will need others to bear their sins.” Faced with this scene, Allah Most High says to the person who was wronged:
– Raise your head and look at the gardens of Paradise, He says. The man raises his head and says:
– O my Lord! I see cities made of silver, and lofty buildings and palaces made of gold and adorned with pearls. Which prophet, which supremely truthful believer or which martyr do these belong to?
– They belong to whoever pays their price/their worth.
– O my Lord! Who could afford that?
– You have the means to pay their price.
– What is it, O my Lord?
– Forgiving your Muslim brother.
– O my Lord! I have forgiven him.
Then Almighty Allah says:
– Take your brother by the hand and take him to Paradise too.
After relating this, the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
– O my Companions! Fear Allah. Settle the disputes among you. Indeed, Allah reconciles the believers.”
This hadith also shows that, if Allah wills, He saves a believer who dies bearing the burden of “violating another person’s rights” by bestowing His bounty from His own treasury, reconciling the two and admitting them to His Paradise hand in hand. All that is required of us as His servants is that, once we recognise our error, we do not persist in it, but repent and advance on the path of serving Allah as He deserves. All that is required is that we please Allah. Even if we cannot satisfy His servants and obtain their pardon, when the person we have wronged sees Allah’s dazzling Paradise, they will relinquish their claim against us with cries of joy.
In conclusion, the rights of others are among the most important matters in Islamic ethics and belief in the hereafter. A person may repent of sins committed against Allah and hope for His forgiveness. But when someone violates another person’s rights, they also bear responsibility for remedying that wrong. In the hereafter, no good or evil deed will go without recompense. Allah will not wrong anyone in the slightest. We must therefore learn not only to fulfil our responsibilities towards Allah, but also to treat other people justly. We must not forget that while we repent of our sins against our Lord and hope for forgiveness, we are also obliged to respect another person’s tears, hard work, property and honour.
A final word: No person’s sin is greater than Allah’s mercy. Yet it is not right to turn Allah’s mercy into an excuse for wronging others. Nor should anyone regard Allah’s mercy as a guarantee of impunity for oppressing someone else. We must both repent and do everything we can to restore what is rightfully owed.
Musab Seyithan
Mirat Haber – YouTube
Today, public institutions conduct their financial transactions, decision-making and resource allocation largely through digital systems…
For years, I have had a system in place: my old vehicle’s HGS tolls were…
Once, a voice rose, placing regard for the Truth above all other considerations. Then those…
There is something we hear often these days: “What matters is being a good person.…
Today, we see significant differences between sections of society. These differences can reach the point…
For many years, we had been exploited through interest. In recent days, a fund racket…