The Islamic State Model That Ensures Security Against Risks: An Interpretation of Surah Quraysh

Modern societies have moved beyond the predictable local dangers of the Industrial Revolution and entered a “Risk Society” phase dominated by unpredictable risks such as nuclear risks, climate crises, pandemics, global terrorist networks and cyber threats. Faced with growing uncertainty and a climate of fear, states are prioritising security concerns, while measures taken in the name of maintaining social order are placing individual freedoms and legal rights under serious pressure. Amid this structural transformation, the modern state no longer derives its legitimacy solely from the conventional distribution of welfare or the traditional maintenance of public order, but also from its function of “protecting society from uncertainties and crises” . The liberal state model’s inability to cope adequately with modern risks has compelled governments to expand their surveillance, oversight and risk management mechanisms. This manifests itself in three main dimensions:

  1. Risk Management and the Preventive State: The risk state is not a reactive structure that responds only after a crime or crisis has occurred. Rather, it is an administration centred on risk management that intervenes before a crisis develops through intelligence, big data analytics, digital surveillance and preventive measures.
  2. Legal Legitimacy and the State of Exception: In modern democracies, the “state of exception”, declared under the pretext of emergencies such as crises, terrorism, economic disasters or pandemics, risks ceasing to be a temporary legal measure and becoming a permanent form of government and the norm. In this process, as the link between the legal order and actual life breaks down, the state of exception becomes permanent, threatening democratic institutions and the separation of powers and blurring the line between democracy and dictatorship.
  3. The Distinction from the Police State and the “Janus Face”: The traditional Police State, whose purpose is to protect those in power and keep society under repressive control, must not be confused with the modern Risk State. The Risk State has the well-intentioned aim of protecting society from global threats; yet when it spirals out of control through security paranoia, it risks assuming a “Janus face” and reverting to an authoritarian Police State. Like the two-faced god of Roman mythology, Janus, the risk state represents a contradictory duality:

– The First Face (The Protective Face): The compassionate, preventive modern face that seeks to protect society from pandemics, terrorism, climate crises and cyberattacks.

– The Second Face (The Repressive Face): The authoritarian face that emerges when security paranoia and excessive surveillance spiral out of control, destroying individual freedoms and bringing society under rigid control.

This dual character of power also occupies a central place in academic analyses of social and psychological dynamics. In this understanding, the state is the sole legitimate actor with a monopoly on coercive power within society. Yet in democratic societies, unless this immense state power is kept in check through institutional oversight and the separation of powers, the door will inevitably be opened to authoritarian regimes, as historical experience has shown. In short, while today’s state model serves as a modern shield protecting society against global risks, it always carries the risk of becoming a repressive sword that stifles freedoms if legal limits are not upheld.

The Role of the State in Islamic Political and Legal Philosophy: Surah Quraysh

In Islamic political and legal philosophy, one of the state’s two most fundamental pillars of legitimacy is justice; the other is security, which ensures stability and peace (el-Emnü vel-İstikrâr). In the Holy Qur’an, Surah Quraysh describes the city/state as enjoying two great blessings: “being fed and delivered from hunger, and being made secure from fear” (min havfin) (Qur’an, Surah Quraysh, 106/4). This shows that, from the outset, security and risk management are regarded as fundamental duties of the state. In modern state sociology, particularly Ulrich Beck‘s Risk Society theory, premodern societies grappled mainly with “the risks of scarcity and hunger“, whereas modern societies are tested by “technological, ecological, epidemiological and security-related crises“. The noble verse directly addresses two fundamental kinds of existential crisis that threaten a society’s existence and sustainability:

  • “Feeding them and delivering them from hunger” (At’amehum min cû’): Economic security, food security, the distribution of welfare and the sustainability of investment.
  • “Making them secure from fear” (Ve âmenehum min havf): Physical safety, preventive security against internal/external threats, and the protection of public order against the risks of pandemics, war and disasters.

The modern Security and Risk State derives its legitimacy precisely from its ability to manage and protect these two areas—socioeconomic security and physical/sociological security—simultaneously. The word “havf” (fear) in the verse expresses not merely a crime that has already occurred or an attack that is underway, but also a perception of future threats, uncertainty and the anticipation of risk. The most distinctive feature of the Security and Risk State is that it is not reactive (responsive), intervening only after a crisis or crime has occurred, but preventive in character, taking precautions before risks materialise. The promise and duty in the noble verse of making society “secure from fear (the social risks that may arise)” obliges the state to strengthen its structures before a crisis arrives, conduct risk analyses and take proactive (anticipatory) measures against factors that threaten society’s survival and security.

A close examination of the verse’s structure shows that “feeding” (economic/social security) and “providing safety” (physical/legal security) are presented as two successive, complementary elements:

  • Genuine public safety and security cannot be established in a society marked by hunger and profound income inequality.
  • Where security and the peace afforded by constitutional order are absent, economic investment, production and prosperity cannot exist.

This shows that the modern models of the “Protective State” (social security and poverty prevention) and the “Security and Risk State” (eliminating threats) are not mutually exclusive. Rather, as stated in verse 4 of Surah Quraysh, they are two complementary areas of fundamental responsibility. On the other hand, the greatest vulnerability of the Security and Risk State model is the risk that, on the grounds of “eliminating fear and threats“, it will completely destroy individual freedoms and turn into a Police State (the Janus face). This divine reference in Surah Quraysh defines security not as an instrument of repression and control, but as a blessing, a source of social peace and a foundation of freedom on which the servant of Allah can lead a dignified life. Thus, in Islamic political philosophy, managing risks and threats does not give public authority licence to exercise arbitrary domination. On the contrary, it imposes on the state a duty to protect individuals’ lives, property and intellect within a framework of justice.

In Conclusion

Verse 4 of Surah Quraysh is a historical and divine synthesis of the functions of the “Security and Risk State” and the “Welfare/Investment State” in modern state theory. The Islamic State is obliged to serve as a preventive and compassionate security shield that protects its society against both economic risks (hunger/poverty) and existential threats (fear/chaos). If only our own leaders understood this and shaped state policies accordingly. For acting with an awareness of security as a divine trust that safeguards citizens’ lives, property and dignity, rather than seeing it merely as an instrument of repression, is also the most fundamental condition of social legitimacy.

Prof. Dr. Ali Seyyar

More articles by this author

Mirat Haber – YouTube

 

Recent Posts

  • Articles

ALGORITHM AUDITING IS ESSENTIAL

Today, public institutions conduct their financial transactions, decision-making and resource allocation largely through digital systems…

1 hour ago
  • Articles

A “Deli Dumrul” Story in the Digital Age

For years, I have had a system in place: my old vehicle’s HGS tolls were…

3 hours ago
  • Articles

THE SINS LAID ON FAITH’S SHOULDERS

Once, a voice rose, placing regard for the Truth above all other considerations. Then those…

5 hours ago
  • Articles

Is Religion Only About Morality?

There is something we hear often these days: “What matters is being a good person.…

5 hours ago
  • Articles

IS THE GENERATION GAP NORMAL?

Today, we see significant differences between sections of society. These differences can reach the point…

5 hours ago
  • Articles

FUND RACKETEERS MANIPULATE ASSET VALUES AND LIVE OFF UNLAWFUL GAINS

For many years, we had been exploited through interest. In recent days, a fund racket…

5 hours ago